data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/63241/632415140fa7dfd41bff3f6dd74bd8daf7b226c8" alt=""
Chris Richardson - The judges were practically humping the Timberlake-wannabe's leg after his nasal, pitchy version of “If I Could Change The World” by Eric Clapton. He turned this rock/blues song into a boy band bore. He should be in the bottom three. As a side note, what was up with that jacket? It looked like the lapel was ripped.
Melinda Doolittle - Mindy Doo was in her element tonight with the gospel-tinged “There Will Come A Day” by Faith Hill. It's impossible to criticize her vocals at this point. She's technically brilliant, and I was digging her hair, dress and necklace. I'm still betting on Mindy and Jordin for the top two.
Blake Lewis - A flat uninspired version of "Imagine” by John Lennon received mixed praise from the judges. Randy and Paula (natch) loved it, while Simon liked it but said it "went nowhere." Blake looks more and more like Phil Collins every week. Personally, I was trying to imagine him having an upper lip.
LaKisha Jones - Oh, Kiki, what the hell are you doing, girlfriend? For the second week in a row, she chose a song by a recent Idol winner and turned it into a shouty, uninspired mess. Tonight it was “I Believe,” Fantasia's coronation song as Idol winner two years ago. Fantasia's career might be a bit shaky now, but she still owns that song. I believe we'll be seeing Kiki in the bottom three tomorrow night.
Phil Stacey - After being heaped with praise and suddenly finding himself a contender, Nosferatu smartly picked another country song, “The Change” by Garth Brooks. It was a nice vocal and he's in his comfort zone, as Paula put it. He won't make it to the top four, but he'll be around for a couple more weeks.
Jordin Sparks - I thought “You’ll Never Walk Alone” from the musical Carousel was an odd choice, but she knocked this old chestnut out of the park. Top two with Melinda. Accept it. Deal with it.
And since we couldn't have Sanjaya, here's his Top 10 list from Letterman last night.
Comments
GAV
LOL. You crack me up. Yup -- Doo and Sparks will be final 2 if America gets it right this year.
blake was awful.
awful.
so was chris.
i don't care what the judges say.
he was terrible.
i didn't think lakisha was all that terrible. i'd put her in 3rd place. behind melinda and jordin. she's definitely not worse than phil.
i'm sorry to say i'm going to have to sit through tonight's episode, live.